Welcome to Jackson County where the pizza is hot, the toppings are plenty, and every slice tells a story. Whether you’re a thin crust connoisseur or someone who lives for gooey, cheesy goodness, this region has it all.
1. Whiffle Boys Pizza – Murphysboro
Our first stop is Whiffle Boys Pizza, the home of bold flavors and fun vibes. Whiffle Boys takes a playful approach to pizza, with quirky names and unexpected topping combinations that’ll excite any foodie.
What to Try: Go for their Whiffle Boy Supreme—a flavor-packed combo of pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms. The crust here strikes a perfect balance between crispy and chewy, making every bite satisfying. If you’re feeling adventurous, don’t miss their Buffalo Chicken Pizza for a spicy kick that will have your taste buds dancing. An unusal pizza that packs a punch is the Chicken Stir Fry Pizza, which you must try to understand! Do not miss out on the Whiffle Sticks as an appitizer (you will be pleased you did).
2. Martel’s Pizza – Murphysboro
Next, we’re hitting up Martel’s Pizza, a beloved staple that’s been serving up slices to Murphysboro and known for its reliable, classic pizza recipes, Martel’s keeps things simple but delicious.
What to Try: Their Deluxe Pizza is a local favorite—piled high with pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. But what really sets Martel’s apart is their ultra-thin crust that stays crispy until the last bite. If you’re a fan of tradition, this is your go-to pizza spot.
3. Cummare’s Italian Ristorante – Murphysboro
Looking for an authentic Italian vibe? Head over to Cummare’s, where the pizza is just the start of an Italian feast. This cozy spot offers traditional Italian pizza with a side of hospitality.
What to Try: You can’t go wrong with their Margherita Pizza—fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce on a perfectly baked crust. It’s simple, light, and bursting with flavor. For something heartier, try the Cummare’s Special, a meat-lover’s dream packed with sausage, pepperoni, and all the classic veggies. If available for lunch, make sure to try the buffett to taste many items from the menu.
4. Scratch Brewery – Ava, IL
For our final stop, is Scratch Brewery in nearby Ava. Scratch is a favorite for craft beer lovers, but they also make a mean wood-fired pizza. You’ll love the rustic vibe here, with pizzas baked in a wood-fired oven that infuses them with a smoky, mouthwatering flavor.
What to Try: Their Wood-Fired Margherita is a must—topped with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil, it’s the perfect mix of simplicity and smoky goodness. Scratch also loves to experiment with seasonal ingredients, so you might find pizzas topped with foraged mushrooms, wild greens, or other local delights.
From classic thin crust at Martel’s to wood-fired wonders at Scratch Brewery, Murphysboro’s pizza scene is packed with variety and flavor. Whether you’re here for a weekend getaway or just a local looking for your next slice, these four spots promise to deliver pizza perfection.
